LP SmartSide Siding — Is It the Right Choice for Your Indiana or Illinois Home?
LP SmartSide has become a serious competitor to James Hardie in the Midwest siding market — and for good reason. But it’s not the right choice for every home or every homeowner. Here’s the honest breakdown.
What LP SmartSide Is
LP SmartSide is an engineered wood siding product manufactured by Louisiana-Pacific. It’s not solid wood — it’s a composite of wood strands bound with resins and treated with a proprietary preservative system called SmartGuard, which provides resistance to moisture, fungal decay, and termites.
The result is a product that looks like wood, can be painted like wood, and performs significantly better than natural wood in harsh climates — while costing less than fiber cement (James Hardie).
How LP SmartSide Performs in Northwest Indiana and Illinois
LP SmartSide was specifically engineered for climate extremes — including the kind of freeze-thaw cycling and moisture exposure that characterizes Lake County, Porter County, and northern Illinois.
Moisture resistance: SmartGuard treatment provides meaningful protection against moisture infiltration, which is critical in our climate. Properly installed LP SmartSide — with all cuts primed and all penetrations caulked — performs well long-term.
Temperature performance: Unlike vinyl, LP SmartSide maintains its physical properties across the temperature range we experience. It doesn’t become brittle in extreme cold or warp in heat.
Impact resistance: Better than vinyl, not quite as good as James Hardie fiber cement. LP SmartSide dents rather than cracks on significant impact — generally more repairable than vinyl but less resistant than Hardie.
Paint retention: Factory primed (not finished — requires field painting) or available pre-finished in select colors. Field-applied paint lasts 8-12 years before repainting is needed — comparable to primed Hardie, less than Hardie’s ColorPlus factory finish.
LP SmartSide vs. James Hardie — The Key Differences
Factor
LP SmartSide
James Hardie
Material
Engineered wood
Fiber cement
Installed cost
Lower by 15-25%
Higher
Weight
Lighter
Heavier
Impact resistance
Good
Excellent
Fire resistance
Treated but wood-based
Non-combustible
Paint finish options
Factory prime or pre-finish
ColorPlus factory finish (15 yr)
Warranty
5/50 year limited
30 year
Natural wood look
Excellent
Good
Where LP SmartSide Wins
Authentic wood appearance: LP SmartSide’s texture more closely mimics real wood grain than Hardie’s smoother fiber cement surface. For craftsman bungalows, historic homes, and properties where authentic wood character matters, SmartSide often looks more natural.
Cost: The 15-25% cost advantage over Hardie is real. For homeowners on a tighter budget who want better than vinyl, LP SmartSide is a compelling middle option.
Weight: Lighter installation makes it easier to handle on tall structures and reduces structural load slightly.
Where James Hardie Wins
Fire resistance: Fiber cement is non-combustible. This matters in communities near wooded areas and provides peace of mind that LP SmartSide’s treated wood cannot fully match.
Paint longevity (ColorPlus): Hardie’s factory-applied ColorPlus finish genuinely lasts 15+ years without repainting. LP SmartSide’s factory prime or pre-finish requires painting within the first year (if primed) or repainting sooner than ColorPlus.
Both products are legitimate choices for Northwest Indiana and Illinois homes. LP SmartSide is the right call when:
– Budget is constrained and you need better than vinyl
– Authentic wood appearance is a priority
– The home is craftsman or traditional style where wood texture fits architecturally
Hardie is the right call when:
– Fire resistance matters
– You want the longest paint warranty with ColorPlus
– You’re maximizing resale value in a market that recognizes Hardie
Call (219) 224-2636 to discuss which is right for your specific home.
About Alamo Roofing Contractors
Alamo Roofing Contractors is a GAF Master Elite certified roofing contractor serving Northwest Indiana and northern Illinois since 2017. Based in Portage, Indiana, we serve Lake County, Porter County, LaPorte County, Cook County, Will County, and DuPage County.
LP SmartSide Siding — Is It the Right Choice for Your Indiana or Illinois Home?
LP SmartSide has become a serious competitor to James Hardie in the Midwest siding market — and for good reason. But it’s not the right choice for every home or every homeowner. Here’s the honest breakdown.
What LP SmartSide Is
LP SmartSide is an engineered wood siding product manufactured by Louisiana-Pacific. It’s not solid wood — it’s a composite of wood strands bound with resins and treated with a proprietary preservative system called SmartGuard, which provides resistance to moisture, fungal decay, and termites.
The result is a product that looks like wood, can be painted like wood, and performs significantly better than natural wood in harsh climates — while costing less than fiber cement (James Hardie).
How LP SmartSide Performs in Northwest Indiana and Illinois
LP SmartSide was specifically engineered for climate extremes — including the kind of freeze-thaw cycling and moisture exposure that characterizes Lake County, Porter County, and northern Illinois.
Moisture resistance: SmartGuard treatment provides meaningful protection against moisture infiltration, which is critical in our climate. Properly installed LP SmartSide — with all cuts primed and all penetrations caulked — performs well long-term.
Temperature performance: Unlike vinyl, LP SmartSide maintains its physical properties across the temperature range we experience. It doesn’t become brittle in extreme cold or warp in heat.
Impact resistance: Better than vinyl, not quite as good as James Hardie fiber cement. LP SmartSide dents rather than cracks on significant impact — generally more repairable than vinyl but less resistant than Hardie.
Paint retention: Factory primed (not finished — requires field painting) or available pre-finished in select colors. Field-applied paint lasts 8-12 years before repainting is needed — comparable to primed Hardie, less than Hardie’s ColorPlus factory finish.
LP SmartSide vs. James Hardie — The Key Differences
Factor
LP SmartSide
James Hardie
Material
Engineered wood
Fiber cement
Installed cost
Lower by 15-25%
Higher
Weight
Lighter
Heavier
Impact resistance
Good
Excellent
Fire resistance
Treated but wood-based
Non-combustible
Paint finish options
Factory prime or pre-finish
ColorPlus factory finish (15 yr)
Warranty
5/50 year limited
30 year
Natural wood look
Excellent
Good
Where LP SmartSide Wins
Authentic wood appearance: LP SmartSide’s texture more closely mimics real wood grain than Hardie’s smoother fiber cement surface. For craftsman bungalows, historic homes, and properties where authentic wood character matters, SmartSide often looks more natural.
Cost: The 15-25% cost advantage over Hardie is real. For homeowners on a tighter budget who want better than vinyl, LP SmartSide is a compelling middle option.
Weight: Lighter installation makes it easier to handle on tall structures and reduces structural load slightly.
Where James Hardie Wins
Fire resistance: Fiber cement is non-combustible. This matters in communities near wooded areas and provides peace of mind that LP SmartSide’s treated wood cannot fully match.
Paint longevity (ColorPlus): Hardie’s factory-applied ColorPlus finish genuinely lasts 15+ years without repainting. LP SmartSide’s factory prime or pre-finish requires painting within the first year (if primed) or repainting sooner than ColorPlus.
Both products are legitimate choices for Northwest Indiana and Illinois homes. LP SmartSide is the right call when:
– Budget is constrained and you need better than vinyl
– Authentic wood appearance is a priority
– The home is craftsman or traditional style where wood texture fits architecturally
Hardie is the right call when:
– Fire resistance matters
– You want the longest paint warranty with ColorPlus
– You’re maximizing resale value in a market that recognizes Hardie
Call (219) 224-2636 to discuss which is right for your specific home.
About Alamo Roofing Contractors
Alamo Roofing Contractors is a GAF Master Elite certified roofing contractor serving Northwest Indiana and northern Illinois since 2017. Based in Portage, Indiana, we serve Lake County, Porter County, LaPorte County, Cook County, Will County, and DuPage County.
LP SmartSide has become a serious competitor to James Hardie in the Midwest siding market — and for good reason. But it’s not the right choice for every home or every homeowner. Here’s the honest breakdown.
What LP SmartSide Is
LP SmartSide is an engineered wood siding product manufactured by Louisiana-Pacific. It’s not solid wood — it’s a composite of wood strands bound with resins and treated with a proprietary preservative system called SmartGuard, which provides resistance to moisture, fungal decay, and termites.
The result is a product that looks like wood, can be painted like wood, and performs significantly better than natural wood in harsh climates — while costing less than fiber cement (James Hardie).
Professional inspection ensures no damage goes undetected
How LP SmartSide Performs in Northwest Indiana and Illinois
LP SmartSide was specifically engineered for climate extremes — including the kind of freeze-thaw cycling and moisture exposure that characterizes Lake County, Porter County, and northern Illinois.
Moisture resistance: SmartGuard treatment provides meaningful protection against moisture infiltration, which is critical in our climate. Properly installed LP SmartSide — with all cuts primed and all penetrations caulked — performs well long-term.
Temperature performance: Unlike vinyl, LP SmartSide maintains its physical properties across the temperature range we experience. It doesn’t become brittle in extreme cold or warp in heat.
Impact resistance: Better than vinyl, not quite as good as James Hardie fiber cement. LP SmartSide dents rather than cracks on significant impact — generally more repairable than vinyl but less resistant than Hardie.
Paint retention: Factory primed (not finished — requires field painting) or available pre-finished in select colors. Field-applied paint lasts 8-12 years before repainting is needed — comparable to primed Hardie, less than Hardie’s ColorPlus factory finish.
LP SmartSide vs. James Hardie — The Key Differences
Factor
LP SmartSide
James Hardie
Material
Engineered wood
Fiber cement
Installed cost
Lower by 15-25%
Higher
Weight
Lighter
Heavier
Impact resistance
Good
Excellent
Fire resistance
Treated but wood-based
Non-combustible
Paint finish options
Factory prime or pre-finish
ColorPlus factory finish (15 yr)
Warranty
5/50 year limited
30 year
Natural wood look
Excellent
Good
Quality materials and expert installation make the difference
Where LP SmartSide Wins
Authentic wood appearance: LP SmartSide’s texture more closely mimics real wood grain than Hardie’s smoother fiber cement surface. For craftsman bungalows, historic homes, and properties where authentic wood character matters, SmartSide often looks more natural.
💡 Pro Tip
Schedule a professional inspection within 30 days of any major storm. Early detection prevents costly repairs down the road.
Cost: The 15-25% cost advantage over Hardie is real. For homeowners on a tighter budget who want better than vinyl, LP SmartSide is a compelling middle option.
Weight: Lighter installation makes it easier to handle on tall structures and reduces structural load slightly.
Alamo Roofing serves Lake County, Porter County & northern Illinois
Where James Hardie Wins
Fire resistance: Fiber cement is non-combustible. This matters in communities near wooded areas and provides peace of mind that LP SmartSide’s treated wood cannot fully match.
Paint longevity (ColorPlus): Hardie’s factory-applied ColorPlus finish genuinely lasts 15+ years without repainting. LP SmartSide’s factory prime or pre-finish requires painting within the first year (if primed) or repainting sooner than ColorPlus.
📞 Need Help?
Alamo Roofing provides free drone inspections across Northwest Indiana. Call (219) 248-2194 for a no-obligation assessment.
James Hardie Board and Batten Siding — A Growing Trend in Northwest Indiana
Board and batten siding has been experiencing a significant revival in Northwest Indiana and northern Illinois — and the contemporary version uses James Hardie fiber cement rather than traditional wood. Here’s what you need to know if you’re considering this look for your home.
What Board and Batten Siding Is
Board and batten is a vertical siding pattern consisting of wide boards installed vertically, with narrow strips (battens) covering the seams between boards. This creates a distinctive textured, vertical-line aesthetic that differs sharply from the horizontal lap siding most Midwest homes use.
The traditional version used wood planks — which required significant maintenance in our climate. James Hardie’s HardiePanel with HardieTrim battens brings this look into the modern era with fiber cement’s durability.
Why It’s Growing in Popularity
Modern farmhouse aesthetic: The board and batten look is synonymous with the modern farmhouse style that has dominated home design for the past decade. It works equally well on new construction and on exterior renovations of existing homes.
Distinctive curb appeal: In neighborhoods full of horizontal lap siding, board and batten stands out — in a positive way. The vertical orientation draws the eye up and can make a home appear taller and more architecturally interesting.
Full exterior or accent use: Board and batten can be used as the primary siding across the entire home, or as an accent on specific architectural elements — gable ends, lower foundations, dormers — paired with horizontal HardiePlank on the rest of the home. This mixed approach is increasingly popular.
Hardie’s durability in our climate: The same fiber cement advantages that make HardiePlank a strong choice apply to HardiePanel — fire resistance, impact resistance, and climate-specific engineering for Midwest freeze-thaw conditions.
How Hardie Board and Batten Installation Works
HardiePanel is installed in large vertical sheets (typically 4×8 or 4×9 feet), then HardieTrim battens are face-nailed over the seams. The system requires:
A weather-resistant barrier (house wrap) over the sheathing
Proper clearance from grade, rooflines, and horizontal surfaces for moisture management
All cut edges must be primed to maintain moisture resistance
All penetrations and trim connections must be caulked with appropriate flexible sealant
Correct installation is critical for both appearance and performance. James Hardie’s installation standards are specific — improper installation voids the material warranty and creates performance problems.
Color and Finish Options
HardiePanel is available in:
– Primed (field-painted): Any color from any paint manufacturer. Requires painting within 180 days of installation. Typical repaint cycle of 8-12 years.
– ColorPlus factory finish: Pre-applied factory bake-on finish in Hardie’s color palette. 15-year color warranty against fading, peeling, and cracking.
ColorPlus in popular board-and-batten colors (particularly Arctic White and Cobblestone) is the most common specification in our market.
What It Costs vs. Traditional Lap Siding
Board and batten installation typically runs 10-20% more than HardiePlank horizontal lap siding due to:
– More material waste in cutting vertical panels to fit irregular elements
– More complex trim and batten installation
– More caulking and sealing requirements
For most homes, the premium is $1,500-$4,000 more than an equivalent horizontal siding project — a modest premium for a significantly different visual result.
Is Board and Batten Right for Your Home?
Works well for:
– Ranch and single-story homes where vertical lines add visual height
– New construction or full exterior renovation
– Farmhouse, craftsman, and contemporary home styles
– Mixed siding approaches (board and batten on gable, lap on walls)
Less ideal for:
– Traditional colonial or Tudor homes where the aesthetic doesn’t fit the architecture
– Homes where budget is a primary constraint
Call (219) 224-2636 to discuss board and batten and get a free siding estimate.
About Alamo Roofing Contractors
Alamo Roofing Contractors is a GAF Master Elite certified roofing contractor serving Northwest Indiana and northern Illinois since 2017. Based in Portage, Indiana at 6064 Lute Rd, we serve Lake County, Porter County, LaPorte County, Cook County, Will County, and DuPage County with residential and commercial roofing, siding, gutters, and exterior services.
Board and batten siding has been experiencing a significant revival in Northwest Indiana and northern Illinois — and the contemporary version uses James Hardie fiber cement rather than traditional wood. Here’s what you need to know if you’re considering this look for your home.
What Board and Batten Siding Is
Board and batten is a vertical siding pattern consisting of wide boards installed vertically, with narrow strips (battens) covering the seams between boards. This creates a distinctive textured, vertical-line aesthetic that differs sharply from the horizontal lap siding most Midwest homes use.
The traditional version used wood planks — which required significant maintenance in our climate. James Hardie’s HardiePanel with HardieTrim battens brings this look into the modern era with fiber cement’s durability.
Professional inspection ensures no damage goes undetected
Why It’s Growing in Popularity
Modern farmhouse aesthetic: The board and batten look is synonymous with the modern farmhouse style that has dominated home design for the past decade. It works equally well on new construction and on exterior renovations of existing homes.
Distinctive curb appeal: In neighborhoods full of horizontal lap siding, board and batten stands out — in a positive way. The vertical orientation draws the eye up and can make a home appear taller and more architecturally interesting.
Full exterior or accent use: Board and batten can be used as the primary siding across the entire home, or as an accent on specific architectural elements — gable ends, lower foundations, dormers — paired with horizontal HardiePlank on the rest of the home. This mixed approach is increasingly popular.
Hardie’s durability in our climate: The same fiber cement advantages that make HardiePlank a strong choice apply to HardiePanel — fire resistance, impact resistance, and climate-specific engineering for Midwest freeze-thaw conditions.
How Hardie Board and Batten Installation Works
HardiePanel is installed in large vertical sheets (typically 4×8 or 4×9 feet), then HardieTrim battens are face-nailed over the seams. The system requires:
A weather-resistant barrier (house wrap) over the sheathing
Proper clearance from grade, rooflines, and horizontal surfaces for moisture management
All cut edges must be primed to maintain moisture resistance
All penetrations and trim connections must be caulked with appropriate flexible sealant
Correct installation is critical for both appearance and performance. James Hardie’s installation standards are specific — improper installation voids the material warranty and creates performance problems.
💡 Pro Tip
Schedule a professional inspection within 30 days of any major storm. Early detection prevents costly repairs down the road.
Quality materials and expert installation make the difference
Color and Finish Options
HardiePanel is available in:
Primed (field-painted): Any color from any paint manufacturer. Requires painting within 180 days of installation. Typical repaint cycle of 8-12 years.
ColorPlus factory finish: Pre-applied factory bake-on finish in Hardie’s color palette. 15-year color warranty against fading, peeling, and cracking.
ColorPlus in popular board-and-batten colors (particularly Arctic White and Cobblestone) is the most common specification in our market.
Alamo Roofing serves Lake County, Porter County & northern Illinois
What It Costs vs. Traditional Lap Siding
Board and batten installation typically runs 10-20% more than HardiePlank horizontal lap siding due to:
20% more than HardiePlank horizontal lap siding due to:
More material waste in cutting vertical panels to fit irregular elements
More complex trim and batten installation
More caulking and sealing requirements
For most homes, the premium is $1,500-$4,000 more than an equivalent horizontal siding project — a modest premium for a significantly different visual result.
📞 Need Help?
Alamo Roofing provides free drone inspections across Northwest Indiana. Call (219) 248-2194 for a no-obligation assessment.
Is Board and Batten Right for Your Home?
Works well for:
– Ranch and single-story homes where vertical lines add visual height
– New construction or full exterior renovation
– Farmhouse, craftsman, and contemporary home styles
– Mixed siding approaches (board and batten on gable, lap on walls)
Less ideal for:
– Traditional colonial or Tudor homes where the aesthetic doesn’t fit the architecture
– Homes where budget is a primary constraint
Many roofing contractors offer more than just roofing services. Among them, some offer siding installation, replacement windows, gutter installation, and other home improvement and maintenance services. Noting this, siding inspection is equally crucial for maintaining your home's integrity. Often overlooked, your home's siding plays a pivotal role in protecting it from the elements, supporting energy efficiency, and enhancing curb appeal.
While many homeowners in Portage Indiana and nearby Crown Point prioritize roof maintenance, neglecting siding can lead to a cascade of problems, including moisture damage, pest infestations, structural issues, and decreased property value. Regular, professional siding inspections are a proactive way to safeguard your investment, so that your home remains comfortable, efficient, and beautiful for years to come. Partnering with a trusted roofer who understands the nuances of siding systems can make all the difference in preserving your home's value and preventing costly repairs down the line.
The Importance of Siding Inspections
Just as with your roof, your home's siding is a critical defense against the elements. Regular inspections can identify problems early, preventing costly damage and maintaining curb appeal. Siding acts as the first line of defense against rain, snow, wind, and sun, shielding the underlying structure from potential harm. Over time, exposure to these elements can take a toll, leading to cracks, warps, and other forms of deterioration. A proactive inspection strategy enables you to catch these issues early, preventing them from escalating into more significant, expensive problems.
Protecting Against the Elements
Damaged or deteriorating siding allows moisture to penetrate your home, leading to mold growth, wood rot, and structural issues. A thorough siding inspection by a qualified contractor can detect these vulnerabilities before they escalate. Moisture intrusion is a common culprit behind many home maintenance headaches. When water seeps behind the siding, it can create a breeding ground for mold and mildew, posing health risks and compromising the structural integrity of your home. Wood rot, another consequence of moisture damage, can weaken the framing and support systems, leading to costly repairs.
Identifying Hidden Issues
A trained contractor will look for subtle signs of damage, such as:
Cracks, gaps, or warps in the siding material
Loose or missing panels
Signs of pests or water damage
Fading or discoloration
These seemingly minor issues can be indicators of more significant underlying problems. For example, small cracks can widen over time, allowing more moisture to penetrate the siding. Loose panels can create entry points for pests, such as insects and rodents, which can cause further damage to your home. Discoloration or fading may indicate that the siding is losing its protective properties, making it more susceptible to damage from the sun and other elements.
Why Choose Your Roofing Contractor for Siding Inspections?
Many roofers also offer siding services, making them a convenient and reliable choice for homeowners. Here is why:
Comprehensive Home Protection: Roofers understand the interconnectedness of your home's exterior. They can assess how the siding and roofing systems work together to protect your property.
Experienced Professionals: A reliable roofer has the expertise to identify potential issues and recommend effective solutions.
Cost-Effective Solutions: By addressing siding problems early, you can prevent more extensive damage and save money on future repairs.
One-Stop Shop: Hiring a roofer who also specializes in siding simplifies the maintenance process and ensures consistent quality.
Partnering with a Trusted Contractor
Selecting the right contractor in Portage Indiana is essential for a successful siding inspection and repair project. Look for a roofer with a proven track record, positive reviews, and comprehensive insurance coverage. A reliable contractor will conduct a thorough inspection, provide a detailed report of their findings, and offer transparent recommendations for repairs or replacements. It is essential to choose a contractor who is licensed, insured, and experienced in working with various types of siding materials.
Learn More About Siding Inspection and How Alamo Can Help
In this informational video, contractors discuss the importance of having your siding inspected alongside your yearly roof inspection and how Alamo Roofing can help you keep your home exterior in great shape, from the ground to the peak of your roof!
Maximize the Value of Your Home
Investing in professional siding services is an investment in your Portage or Crown Point home's long-term health and value. By partnering with a trusted siding and roofing contractor, you can make certain that your home remains protected and beautiful for years to come. Regular siding inspections are not just about preventing damage; they are also about maintaining your home's aesthetic appeal.
Well-maintained siding enhances curb appeal, making your home more attractive to potential buyers and increasing its overall market value. Do not wait until siding problems become major headaches. Proactive inspections and timely repairs are the keys to preserving your home's integrity and maximizing its value. Contact a qualified roofer today to schedule your siding inspection and ensure your home is protected for years to come!
Seeking a Roofer that Aldo Handles Siding?
Contact the Siding and Roofing Contractors at Alamo Roofing!
Call 219-248-2194 Today to Schedule Your Inspection!
