Avg. Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof (2024 Analysis)

by Apr 5, 2024

When it comes to protecting your home from unpredictable weather, your roof is without a question your first line of defense. But with so many options out there, how do you decide between a classic shingle roof or a sturdy, cutting-edge metal one? Don’t worry, in this article we’re diving into the nitty-gritty of these two roof choices in 2024 so that you can make an informed decision.

Inside this blog:

  • Breaking down metal and shingle roofs based on their durability, environmental impact, and installation and maintenance requirements
  • A cost analysis comparing the average costs between metal and shingle roofs for homeowners to consider in 2024
  • 4 factors to consider when choosing between these two roofs for your home

Keep reading to learn which type of roofing system is right for you!

The Battle of the Roofs: Metal vs. Shingle

Metal or shingle? Let’s break it down.


When it comes to your home’s roof, there’s no question that durability is the most important factor in keeping you and your loved ones safe. So, let’s take a closer look at the resilience of these two roofing types.

Metal Roofs


  • Tough as nails
  • Withstands extreme weather conditions like a champ
  • Lifespan of 40-70 years, sometimes even longer

Shingle Roofs

  • Reliable, but not as rugged as metal
  • Prone to damage in harsh weather
  • Lifespan typically around 20-30 years

Environmental Impact

Let’s explore which one of these roofs may have a better impact on our environment.

Metal Roofs

  • Often made from recycled materials
  • Fully recyclable at the end of its life cycle
  • Reflects sunlight, reducing energy consumption for cooling

Shingle Roofs

  • Typically made from asphalt, which is petroleum-based
  • Contributes to landfill waste when replaced
  • Less energy-efficient due to heat absorption

Installation and Maintenance

Time to roll up our sleeves. Which roof is easier to install and maintain?

Metal Roofs

  • Lightweight and easy to install
  • A metal roof installation requires minimal maintenance over its lifespan
  • Prone to denting if not installed properly, though

Shingle Roofs

  • An asphalt shingle roof requires professional installation but generally straightforward
  • More prone to damage and requires regular inspections and repairs
  • Susceptible to moss and algae growth, requiring cleaning

Cost of Metal vs Shingle Roof

Now, let’s talk money. The age-old question: Which roofing option is cheaper upfront and in the long run?

Metal Roof

  • Metal roofing typically has a higher upfront cost
  • Lower long-term cost due to longevity and minimal maintenance
  • Avg. cost per square foot: $7.50 – $12.50

Shingle Roof


  • Asphalt shingles typically have a lower upfront cost compared to metal
  • They may require more frequent repairs and replacements over time, increasing long-term costs
  • Avg. cost per square foot: $3.50 – $7.50

🤔 The Verdict: What’s Right for You?

Choosing between a metal roof and a shingle roof ultimately depends on your priorities and budget. Here are 4 factors to consider:

1. Budget: Opting for Shingles to Mind Your Finances

For those mindful of their financial bottom line, shingles emerge as a prudent choice. With a comparatively modest initial investment, shingle roofs present an appealing avenue to navigate the roofing landscape without draining your savings. However, it’s essential to note that while shingles may alleviate immediate budgetary concerns, they may incur greater long-term expenses due to potential repair and replacement needs.

Thus, while shingles offer an accessible entry point, it’s wise to consider the broader financial implications over time.

2. Longevity: Metal Roofs for Endurance and Investment

In the pursuit of enduring quality, metal roofs emerge as stalwart contenders. Designed to withstand the tests of time, metal roofs boast an impressive lifespan that often outpaces the tenure of homeownership. While the upfront costs may appear steep, viewing it as a strategic investment yields significant returns over the years.

With a metal roof overhead, homeowners can relish in the assurance of prolonged durability, mitigating concerns of frequent repairs or replacements. For those envisioning a lasting legacy within their home, the enduring appeal of metal roofs stands as a compelling choice.

3. Environment: Embracing Sustainability with Metal Roofs

For environmentally-conscious individuals, the allure of metal roofs lies in their eco-friendly credentials. Crafted from recycled materials and boasting recyclability at the end of their lifecycle, metal roofs embody sustainability at its core. Beyond their recyclability, metal roofs serve as champions of energy efficiency, reflecting sunlight to reduce cooling demands.

By opting for a metal roof, homeowners not only minimize their ecological footprint but also contribute to a greener, more sustainable future. For those prioritizing environmental stewardship, the choice of a metal roof aligns seamlessly with their values.

4. Aesthetics: Harmonizing Roofing Choices with Home Style

In the realm of aesthetics, roofing choices play a pivotal role in shaping the visual identity of a home. Whether it’s the timeless charm of shingles or the contemporary allure of metal, each option bears its distinct visual appeal. To ensure harmony between roof and home style, careful consideration of architectural elements and design motifs is paramount. By aligning roofing materials with the overarching aesthetic vision, homeowners can elevate the curb appeal of their abode, enhancing its allure and character.

Ultimately, the choice between shingles and metal roofs serves as a creative expression of homeowners’ stylistic preferences, enriching the visual tapestry of residential landscapes.

🏠 Metal vs Shingle: Which Roof Will You Choose For Your Home?

In the battle of metal vs. shingle roofs, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Both options have their pros and cons, so it’s essential to weigh them carefully before making a decision. Whether you’re drawn to the durability of metal or the classic appeal of shingles, remember to prioritize what’s best for your home and your budget.

Contact our expert team at Alamo Roofing Contractors today and experience top-notch customer service and committed craftsmanship. We can’t wait to hear your questions and ideas about your next home improvement project! Get in touch with us today and we’ll get the ball rolling.

Latest Posts

(219) 224-2636